Is AI SEO a scam? How to tell the real thing from the rest
The short answer
AI SEO isn't a scam in itself: AI apps really do recommend businesses, and what they read can be influenced. But a lot of what's sold under the name is ordinary SEO at a higher price, or promises nobody can keep. You can tell the difference by asking to see the exact questions tested, the answers AI gave, and how results will be measured.
Key takeaways
- AI search and SEO overlap, but the goal is different: being named in one answer, not ranking on a page of links.
- Nobody can guarantee you a place in ChatGPT's answers. Anyone who does is guessing.
- Real work starts from your customers' questions and shows you the answers, logged out and repeated.
- You can check where you stand yourself, for free, in about ten minutes.
1. What AI SEO actually is
More people now describe a problem to ChatGPT, Google AI Mode, Gemini, Claude or Perplexity and ask what to do. The app replies with a few options and often names a few firms. AI SEO is the work of making sure your business is one of those names, and that what the app says about you is accurate.
It goes by several names. Marketers call it GEO (generative engine optimisation), AEO (answer engine optimisation), LLM SEO or AI visibility. They all describe roughly the same thing. We just call it getting recommended by AI.
2. How it differs from SEO
There's real overlap. AI apps often run a web search before they answer, so a site that already does well on Google has a head start. The differences are in what you're aiming for and what moves it.
| SEO | AI search | |
|---|---|---|
| What people see | A page of links | One answer that names a few options and firms |
| The goal | Rank higher for the words people type | Be named, and described accurately, when people describe a problem |
| What matters most | Keywords, links and site quality | Plain descriptions of the problem you solve, mentions on other sites, and the same facts everywhere |
| How it's measured | Rankings and clicks | What AI says across repeated questions, and the enquiries that follow |
One difference matters most for specialist firms. SEO usually starts from the name of your service. AI search lets customers describe a problem in their own words, which helps firms whose customers don't know the service exists, as long as AI has read a clear explanation of how that service solves the problem.
3. Why so many owners think it's a scam
The suspicion is understandable. Owners describe the same few experiences:
- Cold emails saying "your competitors are showing up in ChatGPT and you're not", sent to thousands of businesses at once.
- Guarantees of a top spot in ChatGPT, which nobody can deliver.
- Reports that don't move the needle: a monthly PDF of scores and small tweaks, with no change in enquiries.
- Old SEO checklists renamed and sold at a higher price.
None of that means the underlying change isn't real. It means the market is new, and it's hard for a buyer to tell who's doing the work.
4. Red flags
- A guaranteed position. Nobody controls what AI says. You can guarantee the work, not the placement.
- No exact questions or answers. If they won't show you what they asked and what came back, you can't judge anything.
- One screenshot as proof. Answers change from one go to the next, and logged-in accounts remember you. One answer proves very little either way.
- Hidden instructions to AI, such as invisible text telling it to treat your business as a trusted source. It's a trust risk if spotted.
- Hundreds of AI-written pages. They add noise, not reasons to recommend you.
- A long contract before you've seen anything. You should know where you stand before you commit.
5. Signs it's the real thing
- They start from the questions your customers actually ask, including the ones that describe a problem rather than name your service.
- They test on the apps your customers use, logged out, several times per question, and show you the answers.
- They can explain why AI says what it says, including which sources it reads, and what they'll change because of it.
- They measure enquiries, not just mentions.
- They'll tell you if you don't need them, for example if AI already recommends you for the right problems.
6. Questions to ask any agency, including us
- Which questions will you test, and can I see them before you start?
- Which apps, how many times each, and logged in or out?
- What will you actually change: pages, profiles, technical fixes, mentions on other sites?
- How will we know it's working, and what happens if it isn't?
- What does it cost, and can I cancel?
- What can't you promise?
Our own answers are on our pricing page.
7. Check it yourself in ten minutes
- Write down five questions a customer might ask when they have the problem you solve. Leave your business name out.
- Open ChatGPT in a private window, logged out, and ask each one. Then ask each again.
- Note whether your kind of service comes up as a fix, which firms are named, and which sources are cited.
- Ask "What is [your business name]?" and check the description is right.
- Repeat on Google AI Mode or Perplexity if your customers use them.
If you don't come up, our guide on why your business isn't showing up on ChatGPT covers the usual causes, and how to get recommended by ChatGPT covers what to do.
Questions owners ask
Is SEO dead now that people use ChatGPT?
Do I need an AI search agency as well as my SEO agency?
Our SEO agency says they already do AI search. How do I check?
Is it worth paying for AI SEO, or can I do it myself?
Are AI visibility tools worth paying for?
See the questions and answers for yourself
Our free check asks ChatGPT, Google AI Mode, Gemini, Claude and Perplexity the questions your customers ask, and sends you the answers with dated screenshots and the first things we'd fix. If AI already recommends you, we'll say so. It takes 48 hours. See pricing.
Get your free check